
“We are at a crossroads. There are two possible paths before us—one in which we destroy what is great about the Internet and about how young people use it, and one in which we make smart choices and head toward a bright future in a digital age.” Thus begins the argument in John Palfrey and Urs Gasser’s book Born Digital: Understanding the First Generation of Digital Natives.
This book, which discusses the change today’s digital age has brought to how people— especially the young, the “Digital Natives”— learn and interact with information, should be required reading for everyone like me. That is, anyone who approaches today’s digital culture with some trepidation, some concern, about how the instant access to information and the seemingly reckless sharing of personal information is affecting our society. Unlike some books about today’s emerging technologies, this one acknowledges that there are dangers within this culture that must be addressed; however, the authors stress that the biggest risk today is that “we, as a society, will fail to harness the good that can come from these opportunities, as we seek to head off the worst of the problems. Fear, in many cases, is leading to overreaction, which in turn could give rise to greater problems as young people take detours around the roadblocks we think we are erecting” (9).
And this is why this book is so important for those who fear today’s digital influence—while we may believe that we can halt negative affects by stopping kids from using these technologies without our consent and constant monitoring, this approach might ease our fear, but it won’t “stop” a thing. These changes have happened. The culture is shifting. We can either bury our heads in the sand and continue to talk of how we want things to be, or we can participate in the changes by guiding our young people towards success in what will be their future environment. As Palfrey and Gasser explain: “These changes, to be sure, are not all good, but they will be enduring” (7).
Throughout their book, the authors explain the reasons they’ve discovered for some of the online behaviors of Digital Natives, as well as the many positive results of these behaviors. Among the positives are the Ditial Native’s connections to information; they tend to view information as malleable, and so they can not only control information but also become creators of information. As they are learning from information, they are also gaining the “ability to shape and reshape their cultural understanding” (125). So they are not simply passive consumers of information—which has been the theme behind many an educational pedagogy over the past century— but, rather, they are active participants in the creation of information and knowledge. And encouraging young people to create and disburse information could be one of the best ways to teach them to also analyze and understand the information they encounter (159).
Of course, Palfrey and Gasser also discuss the problems with the Digital Native’s online interaction that we should be concerned with and that we must address. Among these issues are the massive “digital dossiers,” which include the digital information held about each of us, in many different places, that are out of our own control. There are also privacy issues, including the potential for the rules about privacy to change “at the discretion” of an online site, so that the information we post today, believing it to be private and protected, may not stay that way (57). Also, in terms of privacy, much of the information about an individual, available via search engines, has been input by someone else (58). So the ability of an individual to control their own digital presence is less possible every day.
But the beauty of this book is that the authors do not simply drop these problems in the reader’s lap; they do offer valuable solutions and suggestions. In fact, one of the biggest hindrances they point out is the “unnecessary technology gap between young people and many of their parents and teachers” (109). This gap is often what reinforces the fear that non-natives have about the digital future. But instead of banning technologies, much can be done to help young people find their way.
And this is where schools, libraries, and school libraries are key. Palfrey and Gasser emphasize that “schools and libraries should start by putting the learners first. Teachers and administrators need to get serious about figuring out how kids are learning, and they must build digital literacy skills into their core curricula” (253). Schools must teach kids how to navigate the digital environment by allowing them to “do” in digital environments, and technology should be used to support the existing pedagogy (247). In addition, librarians must provide services that adjust to how Digital Natives are now accessing information; they must guide students towards understanding and evaluating the information that they find. One method of doing this could include encouraging young people to use sites that offer recommendations for popular articles, such as Digg.com, providing a “filter” to counteract information overload (199).
In the dawn of this digital age, Born Digital instructs us to join and participate in the transition, instead of attempting to stop it. The Digital Natives of today need librarians who will help them to navigate their new information world, rather than try to shut them out of it.